The FCS recruiting picture is going from foggy to a tad bit more in focus, and we at HERO Sports figured we’d put together a preliminary national ranking — both for individual commitments to the FCS, and for schools. We will not attempt to rank again until we begin getting closer to the February national signing period opening up, as the FCS postseason will be the lone focus from now until we get past the national championship game in Frisco, Texas.
Ah yes, the team rankings. So how do we arrive at these rankings? Well folks, I’ve spent months vetting the nearly 600 high school recruits I have verified as FCS commitments up to this point. Transfers don’t figure into this, we’ll rank them at a much later date. I’ve used a tiered point system to assign weight to the scholarship offers these athletes have received, then I added up each school’s recruits (the schools are not allowed to publicize their classes yet, so I’ve looked at diehard fan blogs, asked current recruits for their lists (recruits can talk, schools can’t) and also searched social media using school’s recruiting hashtags to follow the news. It is a meticulous process, one that no one else has attempted to do. But this list is accurate as of Nov. 20.
Every commitment to a school helps his future school’s team ranking. The more offers a recruit has, the more coveted he obvious was and the bigger recruiting victory he was for the school. Now, this isn’t trying to predict the next Carson Wentz or P.J. Hall … we know that young men possessing only one or two offers sometimes become All-Americans and NFL Draft picks because they flourish at the college level. This is only meant to show which recruits held multiple offers, and did they have FBS and P5 options also. When a recruit has 23 offers, including 10 from FBS schools … that’s a big “recruiting win” for an FCS staff, and trust me, they get happy about it.
Here are the rankings:
TEAM RANKING (as of Nov. 20)
RK | TEAM |
1 | Princeton |
2 | Harvard |
3 | JMU |
4 | Yale |
5 | NDSU |
6 | Penn |
7 | Furman |
8 | Delaware |
9 | So. Dakota |
10 | Holy Cross |
11 | Columbia |
12 | East. Kentucky |
13 | So. Dakota St. |
14 | UC Davis |
15 | Richmond |
16 | Villanova |
17 | Montana St. |
18 | Mercer |
19 | So. Illinois |
20 | Samford |
21 | UT Martin |
22 | Missouri St. |
23 | Illinois St. |
24 | East. Wash. |
25 | Youngstown St. |
TOP RECRUITS (as of Nov. 20)
NOTE: These high school recruits are ranked by how many other college options these commitments had, and who those offers came from. This is NOT using the star system from any of the recruiting services (and never will).
NOV RK | FCS TEAM | POS | PROSPECT | HOMETOWN | OTHER D-1 OPTIONS |
1 | SOUTH DAKOTA | LB | Vincent Starling | Palm Beach, FL | USF decommit – 8 P5s, 18 FBS |
2 | COLUMBIA | TE | Dominic Busby | West Orange, NJ | Rutgers, Maryland, 12 G5s, 12 FCS |
3 | YALE | OL | Michael Leone | Princeton, NJ | Maryland, Kansas, 8 G5, 18 FCS |
4 | JACKSONVILLE STATE | WR | Jayson Jones | Birmingham, AL | 6 P5s, 6 G5s |
5 | DELAWARE | DT | Fintan Brose | Greensburg, PA | Vandy, 11 FBS, 13 FCS |
6 | JAMES MADISON | OL | Tyler Stephens | Virginia Beach, VA | 11 FBS offers, 25 total |
7 | HARVARD | TE | Tyler Neville | Williamsburg, VA | 9 FBS offers, 18 FCS |
8 | JAMES MADISON | DB | Antonio Webb | Norfolk, VA | UVA, Pitt, Rutgers, 10 FBS |
9 | PRINCETON | OL | Mac Duda | Jefferson Hills, PA | 6 FBS, 20 FCS |
10 | PRINCETON | TE | Tyler Picinic | New Milford, NJ | 6 FBS, 20 FCS |
11 | HARVARD | DE | Tyler Huenemann | Mount Pleasant, MI | 11 FBS offers, 9 FCS offers |
12 | PRINCETON | QB | Blaine McAllister | Atlanta, GA | N.C. State, 11 FBS offers, 5 Ivys |
13 | PRINCETON | LB | Austin Nicholas | Encinitas, CA | 4 P5, 7 G5, 5 Ivys |
14 | IDAHO | QB | Caleb Jordan | Camas, WA | Louisville, 5 G5, 13 FCS offers |
15 | KENNESAW ST. | QB | DeAngelo Hardy | Chattanooga, TN | 4 FBS, 19 FCS offers |
16 | NDSU | TE | Joe Stoffel | River Falls, WI | 11 FBS offers, 4 FCS |
17 | DELAWARE | DE | R.J. McNamara | Lansdale, PA | 5 FBS offers, 15 total offers |
18 | YALE | DL | Zion Dayne | Lorton, VA | 3 FBS, 19 FCS |
19 | JAMES MADISON | DL | Tyler Negron | Nokesville, VA | 6 FBS, 12 FCS |
20 | HARVARD | OL | Logan Bednar | Bellflower, CA | Kansas, Air Force, 18 total offers |
21 | PENN | DB | Shiloh Means | Indianapolis, IN | 9 FBS, 6 FCS offers |
22 | YALE | OL | Bennie Anderson | St. Louis, MO | 5 FBS offers, 16 FCS offers |
23 | FURMAN | LB | Evan DiMaggio | Buford, GA | 11 FBS offers, 2 FCS |
24 | VILLANOVA | QB | Ricky Ortega | Coatesville, PA | Army, Air Force, 18 FCS |
25 | MISSOURI STATE | DL | Armon Wallace | St. Louis, MO | Kentucky, Syracuse, 6 FBS, 11 total |
26 | SDSU | DE | Brandon Lane | Lees Summit, MO | 7 FBS, 5 MVFC, 7 FCS |
27 | CENT. ARKANSAS | RB | Trysten Smith | Duncanville, TX | Kansas, 4 FBS, 11 total |
28 | VILLANOVA | WR | Dapree Bryant | Coatesville, PA | 5 FBS, 12 FCS |
29 | HARVARD | OL | Jake Lugg | Wexford, PA | Nebraska, 6 G5 offers, 6 FCS |
30 | PENN | DL | Henry Iloanya | Washington, DC | Rutgers, 4 G5, 10 FCS |
31 | HOLY CROSS | DB | Terrence Spence | Ringwood, NJ | 5 FBS, 12 FCS offers |
32 | JAMES MADISON | OL | Cole Potts | Columbus, OH | 6 FBS, 9 FCS |
33 | PENN | DB | Henry Blackburn | Boulder, CO | 5 FBS, 11 FCS |
34 | PRINCETON | WR | JoJo Hawkins | Orange, CA | 6 FBS, 9 FCS |
35 | NDSU | DB | Cole Wisniewski | Sparta, WI | 4 FBS, 17 total offers |
36 | TENN-MARTIN | RB | Patrick Bowen | Fort Lauderdale, FL | BostColl, Maryl., 8 FBS, 5 FCS |
37 | HARVARD | DL | Micaiah Bell | Acworth, GA | 2 FBS, 16 FCS |
38 | HARVARD | OL | Jake Rizy | Westport, CT | BostColl., 4 G5, 8 FCS |
39 | HARVARD | RB | Israel Benjamin | Scottsdale, AZ | BYU, Navy, Army, 14 FCS |
40 | PENN | WR | Josh Casilli | McMurray, PA | 2 FBS, 16 FCS |
41 | YALE | DL | Mitchell Tyler | McKinney, TX | Baylor, Kansas, 5 G5, 2 FCS |
42 | NDSU | DE | Seth Anderson | Moorhead, MN | Kansas, 5 FBS, 4 MVFC |
43 | FURMAN | OL | Dylan Davis | Bradenton, FL | Illinois, Iowa St., Army, 5 FCS |
44 | COLUMBIA | TE | Stephen Brooks | Brookline, MA | 3 FBS, 13 FCS |
45 | HARVARD | QB | Caleb Holstein | Lafayette, LA | Mizzou, B.C., 8 G5, 3 FCS offers |
46 | FURMAN | OL | E.J. Wilson | Xenia, OH | 3 FBS, 13 FCS offers |
47 | TENN-MARTIN | RB | Andrew Henley | Hallandale, FL | Virginia, NC State, 3 FCS |
48 | BUCKNELL | DB | Ivan Yates | Roswell, GA | 4 FBS, 10 FCS |
49 | TENNESSEE STATE | QB | Edwin Rhodes | Fort Lauderdale, FL | Vandy, 3 FBS, 5 FCS |
50 | DELAWARE | DL | Jack Hall | Richmond, VA | 2 FBS, 13 FCS offers |