HEROSPORTS
  • Home
  • FCS
    • FCS Home
    • Big South-OVC
    • Big Sky
    • CAA
    • Ivy
    • MEAC
    • MVFC
    • NEC
    • Patriot
    • Pioneer
    • SoCon
    • Southland
    • SWAC
    • UAC
  • FBS
    • FBS Home
    • AAC Football
    • CUSA Football
    • MAC Football
    • Mountain West Football
    • Sun Belt Football
  • College Basketball
  • Register at BetMGM
  • BetMGM Promotions
  • More
    • About HERO Sports
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • FCS
    • FCS Home
    • Big South-OVC
    • Big Sky
    • CAA
    • Ivy
    • MEAC
    • MVFC
    • NEC
    • Patriot
    • Pioneer
    • SoCon
    • Southland
    • SWAC
    • UAC
  • FBS
    • FBS Home
    • AAC Football
    • CUSA Football
    • MAC Football
    • Mountain West Football
    • Sun Belt Football
  • College Basketball
  • Register at BetMGM
  • BetMGM Promotions
  • More
    • About HERO Sports
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
HEROSPORTS
No Result
View All Result

Worst Trades in NFL History Involving a 1st-Round Draft Pick

HERO Sports by HERO Sports
April 8, 2017
Worst Trades in NFL History Involving a 1st-Round Draft Pick

Once upon a time, teams clamored for elite running backs. And once upon a time, the New Orleans Saints traded EIGHT picks to get one. Ricky Williams to be specific.

It wasn't shocking that they wanted the Heisman Trophy winner, but it was shocking when they gave up six picks in the 1999 draft and two more in 2000 to move up seven spots — from No. 12 to No. 5. Williams wasn't bad in New Orleans (3,129 rushing yards and 16 touchdowns in three seasons) but would've needed three straight 2,000-yard seasons and three straight playoff runs (19 total wins, one playoff appearance and no playoff wins) to remotely justify spending eight picks.

RELATED: The Value of Each 2017 NFL Draft Slot

On second thought, almost nothing could justify that investment.

Though the eight-pick trade was embarrassing in retrospect — especially since the Redskins used those picks to select Champ Bailey and LaVar Arrington, among others — the Saints did get two first-rounders back when they dealt Williams to the Miami Dolphins in 2002. 

It was one of the worst trades in NFL history that involved a first-round pick. Here are some others:

[divider]

Herschel Walker – 1989

AKA "The Trade that made the Cowboys Dynasty"

Teams: Dallas Cowboys and Minnesota Vikings

Cowboys Get: 
LB Jesse Solomon
LB David Howard
CB Issiac Holt
DE Alex Stewart
RB Darrin Nelson
1990 1st (No. 21), 2nd (No. 47), 6th (No. 158)
1991 1st (No. 12), 2nd (No. 38)
1992 2nd (No. 37), 3rd (No. 71)
1993 1st (No. 13) 

Vikings Get: 
RB Herschel Walker
1990 3rd (No. 54), 5th (No. 116), 10th (No. 249)
1991 3rd (No. 68) 

Don't bother trying to sort through this mess of a trade that Dallas pulled off in 1989 — just watch the 30 for 30 short: The Great Trade Robbery. 

It was the largest trade in NFL history, one that involved six players and 12 draft picks, including two first-rounders. Walker couldn't have done anything to make this trade worth the Vikings' five players and eight picks, but his mediocre two-plus years (2,264 rushing yards, 20 touchdowns) in Minnesota didn't help.

[divider]

Robert Griffin III – 2012

Teams: St. Louis Rams and Washington Redskins

Rams Get:
2012 1st (No. 6), 2nd (No. 39)
2013 1st (No. 22)
2014 1st (No. 2)

Redskins Get:
2012 1st (No. 2) 

Robert Griffin III would've needed to become a perennial Pro Bowler and borderline Hall of Famer to make the Redskins' aggressive trade worthwhile. And it seemed like he might be headed that way his rookie year, as he set records for passer rating and TD-INT ratio for first-year players and led Washington to their first home playoff game since 1999. But then, in that 24-14 wildcard loss to the Seahawks, he suffered the knee injury that seems to have basically ended his career. 

The Redskins ended up releasing Griffin at the end of the 2015 season, after he had already lost the starting job to Kirk Cousins.

On the other side of the trade, the Rams continued to wheel and deal their picks, eventually using them to acquire Janoris Jenkins, Greg Robinson, Alec Ogletree and Michael Brockers, among others. Though that quartet and others didn't lead the Rams to any division titles, they created a decent roster in exchange for moving down four picks.

[divider]

Jeff George – 1994

Teams: Atlanta Falcons and Indianapolis Colts 

Falcons Get:
QB Jeff George Trade 

Colts Get: 
1994 1st (No. 7), 3rd (No. 83)
1996 1st (No. 19)

In four seasons with Indianapolis, former top-overall pick (1990) Jeff George was never good. In fact, he was terrible, completing less than 60 percent of his passes and throwing more interceptions (36) than touchdowns (31). But that was enough for the Falcons to want him — and pay a king's ransom.

The Colts landed Marvin Harrison with the No. 19 pick in the 1996 draft — which jumped from a second-round to first-rounder after George eclipsed 75 percent of the Falcons' snaps and won nine games in 1995. While George was better in Atlanta (50 touchdowns, 32 interceptions), giving up two first-rounders was outrageous then and still outrageous now.

[divider]

John Hadl – 1974

Teams: Green Bay Packers and Los Angeles Rams

Packers Get: 
QB John Hadl

Rams Get:
1975 1st (No. 9), 2nd (No. 28), 3rd (No. 61)
1976 1st (No. 8), 2nd (No. 39) 

​In the middle of the 1974 season, the Packers mortgaged their immediate future for a 34-year-old quarterback who tossed 26 interceptions (15 touchdowns) two years prior. And it was a big reason for misery over the next decade.

Hadl was downright awful in 19 starts with Green Bay, throwing nine touchdowns and 21 interceptions while winning seven games. The Rams used the picks acquire defensive backs Monte Jackson, Pat Thomas and Nolan Cromwell, and win six straight NFC West titles.

[divider]

Rob Johnson – 1998

Teams: Buffalo Bills and Jacksonville Jaguars

Bills Get: 
QB ​Rob Johnson

Jaguars Get:
1998 1st (No. 9), 4th (No. 101) 

Before Matt Flynning there was Rob Johnsoning, and the Buffalo Bills got ruthlessly Rob Johnsoned. 

Johnson was a fourth-round pick in 1995 and started one total game in his first three years, throwing for a total of 368 yards, two scores and three interceptions. Both touchdowns and nearly all those yards (294) came in a Week 1 start against the Baltimore Ravens, which was enough for the Bills to bet big.

In five years with Buffalo, Johnson threw for more than 1,500 yards once and went 9-17. The Jaguars, meanwhile, took 11,000-yard rusher Fred Taylor with the ninth-overall pick.

[divider]

Ryan Leaf – 1998

Teams: Arizona Cardinals and San Diego Chargers

Cardinals Get: 
KR/PR/WR/RB Eric Metcalf
LB Patrick Sapp
1998 1st (No. 3), 2nd (No. 33)
1999 1st (No. 8)

Chargers:
1998 1st (No. 2)

Lost in the Ryan Leaf fiasco is what the Chargers paid to get him. 

Washington State's Ryan Leaf and Tennessee's Peyton Manning were considered the sure-fire top two quarterbacks in the 1998 class, so the Chargers only needed to move up one spot to No. 2 to draft whichever one the Colts didn't. And they gave up two players and three picks to do it, including two first-rounders. 

The three picks netted the Cardinals defensive tackle Andre Wadsworth, cornerback Corey Chavous and receiver David Boston, who helped the Cardinals win their first playoff game in six decades. Leaf threw a whopping 33 interceptions in 21 appearances for the Chargers and was out of the league after the 2000 season.

split-fbo-6-23-25
Previous Post

NFL Draft: Can High School Prospects Make the Jump Straight to the NFL?

Next Post

UCLA Commit Jaylen Hands Jumps Over Parents in Dunk Contest

Next Post
UCLA Commit Jaylen Hands Jumps Over Parents in Dunk Contest

UCLA Commit Jaylen Hands Jumps Over Parents in Dunk Contest

No Result
View All Result

Recent Posts

  • 2025 FCS Jersey Countdown: The Best Returning Player For Each Number
  • 2025 FCS Top 25: No. 7 Montana Football Preview
  • When Is Week 0?

HERO Sports is the go-to website for FBS and FCS football news, analysis, and predictions.

Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER (Available in the US)
877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369) (NY)
1-800-327-5050 (MA), 1-800-NEXT-STEP (AZ), 1-800-BETS-OFF (IA), 1-800-981-0023 (PR)

For new customer offers, Bonus Bets expire in seven days. One New Customer Offer only. Add'l terms. For existing customers, Bonus Bets expire in seven days. Add'l terms.

21+ only. Please Gamble Responsibly. See BetMGM.com for Terms. First Bet Offer for new customers only (if applicable). Subject to eligibility requirements. Bonus bets are non-withdrawable. In partnership with Kansas Crossing Casino and Hotel. This promotional offer is not available in DC, Mississippi, New York, Nevada, Ontario, or Puerto Rico.

Welcome Offer Bet $10, $150 in Bonus Bets

GAMBLING PROBLEM? CALL 1-800-GAMBLER (AVAILABLE IN THE US). 21+ ONLY. CO, MI, NJ, PA, WV ONLY. PLEASE GAMBLE RESPONSIBLY. SEE BETMGM.COM FOR TERMS. THIS PROMOTIONAL OFFER IS FOR NEW PLAYERS ONLY. SUBJECT TO ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS. BONUS BETS ARE NON-WITHDRAWABLE. US PROMOTIONAL OFFERS NOT AVAILABLE IN MISSISSIPPI, NEVADA, NEW YORK, ONTARIO AND PUERTO RICO.

  • About HERO Sports
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

© 2022 HERO SPORTS.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • FCS
    • FCS Home
    • Big South-OVC
    • Big Sky
    • CAA
    • Ivy
    • MEAC
    • MVFC
    • NEC
    • Patriot
    • Pioneer
    • SoCon
    • Southland
    • SWAC
    • UAC
  • FBS
    • FBS Home
    • AAC Football
    • CUSA Football
    • MAC Football
    • Mountain West Football
    • Sun Belt Football
  • College Basketball
  • Register at BetMGM
  • BetMGM Promotions
  • More
    • About HERO Sports
    • Contact

© 2022 HERO SPORTS.