The No. 5 play on this list that was made by Colorado Rockies pitcher Zac Rosscup is an interesting one. Whenever a play occurs that the announcer is shocked by, you know something a little weird took place. On this play, Rosscup catches a ball lined back up the middle with a little double clutch that even seems to take the pitcher himself by surprise. Check it out in the video.
MORE: MLB Plays of the Day (September 13, 2017) Include Matt Olson, Brett Phillips
